Amateur Chamber Music Society Inc.
What's Self-Grading?
ACMS members grade themselves into five levels of competence (numbered 1
(highest) to 5 (lowest)).
Want to work out your grading? There are two ways:
Before you start:
Remember that self-grading is not a hard and fast science, and everyone's
interpretation of the questionnaire will be personal to some extent.
You may like to consider the following explanations, contibuted by Rod Tuson.
They might help lessen some of the uncertainties for you.
- How daily is 'daily practice'?
'Daily' means most days, that is in a typical month where you are not travelling
overseas, camping, or otherwise unusually unable to practice, you would practice
at least an average of four days a week, each session being 30 minutes or more.
The practice subject should be technical items such as bowing, scales,
technically challenging parts of chamber music.
Just playing through a work for pleasure doesn't count.
Playing as a regular group should not be counted as this is addressed in
question 2.
- How often is 'often'? (as in playing in groups)
A full morning, afternoon or evening session with a chamber group can be defined
as 'one'. So if a full day plus evening session is organised once each week with
your group, it can be counted as three groups. The aberrant period of Christmas,
when it can be difficult to get together, can be ignored in the calculation. If a
regular group comprises only two members, the gatherings should be halved.
- How lost is 'lost'?
This assumes you are playing in a group of three to five players, all of whom are as -
or slightly more - experienced than yourself. You are sight-reading a work you have
not played or heard (or only once at least several months ago). The work is one
that, within a week or two of normal practice, you would be 'comfortable' with.
'Lost' means missing notes or playing in the wrong place for at least 2 bars in
Allegretto or faster, or 1 bar when slower than Allegretto. That is, missing a few
semiquavers in a difficult run or leaving out some of the piano's left-hand notes
does not constitute being 'lost'.
Note that if you find your way back within the bar or two
defined above you haven't been 'lost'. But you can't have your cake and eat it too:
if you recovered quickly as above and haven't counted it as 'lost', you can't then
count this as 'finding your way back' in question 3.
- Finding your way back
You have found your way back if, without stopping, you rejoin the group within
a phrase or by the next GP or conspicuous Sforzando, whichever is the shorter
period. So if the group stops, or continues to play without you beyond a phrase,
you haven't found your way back.
- What's 'comfortable'?
Comfort is defined in the context of a well-matched group playing through a work for
their own pleasure, not in public performance, and not necessarily with public
performance in mind.
You may have played the work many times before or can sight-read it comfortably,
but the question assumes there is no forewarning, so you have no opportunity
to specially practice it beforehand.
It means that you can play the work in whole without getting lost and that wrong
notes and timing errors are sufficiently few that stopping would be a matter of
choice rather than necessity. The tempi need not be professional speed but at least,
say, 70%, so as to have the right feel to the music.
Most (at least 70%) of the dynamics and phrasing marks should be observed. For
strings, bowing directions need not be observed provided style and expression
marks are largely (70%) correct.
Now: on with your self-grading!
back to main menu